Showing posts with label George Lucas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label George Lucas. Show all posts

Thursday, March 23, 2017

Fathers and Sons: Part IV

On May 25th in 1977, the art of cinema changed forever.  The original Star Wars film affected the whole world, and nobody who has seen the film can deny its impact or its cultural significance.  After nearly forty years, in my opinion it is still the greatest movie ever made.

Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope is the fourth film in the Star Wars saga, and is the story of a young farmer who joins forces with an old Jedi Knight to save the galaxy from the evil Galactic Empire.  As so many great films do, this film takes the time to set up the characters.  We find out who Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill), Princess Leia Organa (Carrie Fisher), Han Solo (Harrison Ford) and Obi-Wan Kenobi (Alec Guinness) are, what they do and what their intentions are.  The forces of good and evil are so clearly defined in the film.  The Empire seeks out to destroy those who do not submit to their rule, and the Rebellion fights them in an attempt to prevent them from doing so.  You also get a sense early in the film of how powerful Darth Vader is, and because of this you are either scared of him or thrilled by him throughout the film.  You can also dig into the psychology of Vader a bit with this film.  I have heard people question why Vader does not go down to Tatooine himself to attempt to retrieve the escape pod in the beginning of the film.  I would say that he does not want to go anywhere near the planet where he lost his mother.  This is a location that causes him extreme emotional pain, and he wants to avoid that as much as possible.  I also like that you get the sense that Luke and Obi-Wan are familiar with each other even before their meeting in this film.  This adds more weight to their relationship.  Moving on, I love the way the creatures communicate in the film.  While we may not understand what R2-D2 (Kenny Baker) or Chewbacca (Peter Mayhew) are saying, their companions C-3P0 (Anthony Daniels) and Han Solo, respectively, respond in a way that we can assume what the other was saying.  When I watched this movie for the first time many years ago, I realized even then that I was a science fiction junkie.  Even as a teenager, the words "navicomputer" and "lightspeed" did not seem foreign to me.  I understood what they meant.  The language in this movie is one of the principal reasons Star Wars feels other-worldly.  A good portion of the film takes place on the desert planet Tatooine.  One would think that watching characters trudge through a desert in a movie with the word "Wars" in the title would be boring, however because of the interactions with all of the different characters and the dialogue between them, you truly get invested with the characters and care about what happens to them.  All of the action sequences are some of the most exciting ever filmed, especially the final act when the Rebellion is attacking the Death Star.  The explosion of Alderaan is still one of the most awe-inspiring moments I have ever seen in a film.  I have always pictured in my head that the duel between Darth Vader and Obi-Wan Kenobi was not so much a fight so much as it was meant to be a distraction so Vader would not find out that the rebels were escaping.  One of the concepts that this film introduced was the idea of a "used future".  Instead of everything being shiny and glossy, the world that Star Wars inhabits looks like people have lived there for a long time.  This is a concept that has influenced countless films, and is one of the major reasons Star Wars resonates with its fans.

There are only a few minor flaws I have with the film.  Early in the film, Aunt Beru (Shelagh Fraser) tells Luke to tell Uncle Owen (Phil Brown) to make sure the translator droid speaks Bocce, but Luke never does this.  Now, I can forgive this because Owen actually asks C-3P0 this himself without being reminded.  The glaring problem I have with this movie is near the end. After the rebels destroy the TIE Fighters near the climax of the film, they head to the rebel base to prepare for the coming battle.  The only problem is that we are never told that this is where they are headed.  We must assume that Princess Leia knows where it is, but because we never see a scene where she tells them to head there, we do not know what that place is until the crew actually get there.  Also, how the hell did Luke become a pilot in the Rebellion so quickly??  Did he go through some kind of training that we did not see??  It just seems to me that the film rushes a bit to get to the climactic final act.

Other than these issues, this film is flawless in every single way.  Unlike the previous three films, it is not the visual effects that you remember most about Star Wars.  While they are spectacular, it is the characters that you truly fall in love with and are what bring you back to watch the film over and over again endlessly.

Mark Hamill plays Luke Skywalker.  The key characteristic about Luke is that he wants a better life for himself.  He wants to get away from moisture farming and join the Rebellion to fight the Empire.  Yes, he is reluctant at first, as every hero is, but when the opportunity ultimately presents itself he is determined to achieve his goal.  It is because of all of this that you cheer for Luke throughout the film.  He wants to escape his surroundings and better himself, and that is what it means to be human.  This is what makes the character so identifiable, and Hamill gives a truly authentic performance.

Carrie Fisher plays Princess Leia Organa.  When it comes to strong female characters, Leia was the one who started it all.  While Leia in this film is certainly a "damsel in distress", she is also quite intelligent and knows how to hold her own in battle.  Watching her lead the Rebellion in the fight against the Empire is incredibly inspiring.  The key thing is that Leia does not kick ass because she was written that way.  Instead, Leia kicks ass because Carrie Fisher played her that way.  I am still deeply saddened by her death.  Every world has their princess, and Carrie Fisher was ours.  The world loved her, and she will be forever missed.

Harrison Ford plays Han Solo.  Solo is the smart-ass of the group, motivated by greed and caring only about himself.  Ford taps into something special playing the part because even though Solo is helping the others on their journey, he is not a likeable character at all until the final minutes of the movie.  When he shows up to save Luke his true colors are shown.  It takes a great actor to play a character like this, and Fords' understanding of the character makes for an indelible performance.

Alec Guinness plays Obi-Wan Kenobi.  This is my personal favorite performance in the film.  Guinness plays the role with such gravitas that he immediately grabs your attention the first time you see him.  The way he delivers his lines gives such an emotional weight to the character.  The scene where he is telling Luke about his father is wonderful because you can see in Guinness' eyes that he is remembering everything that happened.  Also, because Obi-Wan is helping Luke train to become a Jedi, you care about what happens to him as well.  His death scene is nothing short of emotional.  I have heard many people criticize the fact that Obi-Wan lies to Luke about who his father really is and that his father wanted him to have his lightsaber.  My response to that is that he lies to Luke to motivate him.  He wants Luke to become a Jedi, and bring peace to the galaxy.  Lying to Luke shows how desperate the Jedi Order is.  Guinness' performance gives the film such a degree of credibility, and truly makes you believe in the story.  This is an excellent performance by a great screen actor, and it is indeed worthy of the Best Supporting Actor nomination that he received.

George Lucas is the director of Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope.  As I mentioned before, this film takes the time to set up the world and the characters inhabiting it, which is a credit to Lucas' writing as well.  What I have always found extraordinary about this film is that Lucas made the most important character a non-human.  R2-D2 is the one who is carrying the technical readouts of the Death Star, and without him the rebels do not win.  It is because of this that you arguably care about R2 the most throughout the movie.  This film also borrows from legendary mythological tales when it comes to the characters.  You have the dashing young hero, the damsel in distress, the anti-hero, and the old wizard.  From a storytelling perspective, I love the fact that Luke's journey is mirrored by the Empire coming closer to their goal, and that this ultimately leads to the two intercepting when the Millenium Falcon gets captured.  The final act of the film is edited brilliantly, and the stakes increase greatly every second.  This film marks the beginning of a wonderful morality tale about a man who seeks to escape his environment and achieve a personal goal, and you cannot help but cheer the whole way through.  Luke Skywalkers' journey in this particular film echoes George Lucas' journey as a filmmaker, and that is probably why this movie has a personal feeling to it.  What Lucas captured with this film is truly magical, and will never be duplicated.

Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope is one of cinemas' most influential films.  It has a great story, wonderful characters, and spectacular visual effects.  If you have not seen this film by now, I highly recommend that you do so, especially for the 40th anniversary!

Monday, February 6, 2017

Fathers and Sons: Part III

Among Star Wars fans who despise the prequels, Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith is known to be the best of the three movies.  The film certainly has its problems, but it also feels more like Star Wars than the previous two films.  This is the story that every Star Wars fan was waiting to see from the beginning.

Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith is the third installment in the Star Wars saga, and is the story of Anakin Skywalkers' turn to the dark side and conversion into Darth Vader.  While this certainly is the most predictable film in the Skywalker story, it does have some moments of surprise.  We already know what happens in the movie, but we do not know how or why.  This movie explains everything in detail, and wraps everything up in an Imperial bow at the end.  So let us begin, as always, with the good parts of the film.

As in all the Star Wars films, the action sequences and lightsaber duels are absolutely thrilling to watch.  More specifically, the opening shot in the film is something I find quite breathtaking.  Visually speaking, everything (including the kitchen sink if you watch closely) is included in the shot.  This leads us to a 2-on-1 lightsaber duel with Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) and Anakin Skywalker (Hayden Christensen) battling Count Dooku (Christopher Lee).  If the first fifteen minutes of the film do not feel like Star Wars, I do not know what does.  It also goes without saying that the planet and sound design is top-notch.  Because this movie is much closer to A New Hope in the timeline, certain ships have familiar sounds.  I also love all the different noises the creatures and droids make.  The planets of Mustafar and Utapau are extremely creative, and are inhabited by beings that are equally as creative, and look quite menacing.  Speaking of the ships, I like seeing early versions of X-Wings and TIE Fighters, and knowing that these ships existed long before we saw them in A New Hope. I also enjoy seeing the bond that has formed between Obi-Wan and Anakin.  They no longer argue with one another, and have become more like brothers.  We also see Anakin pilot, as Obi-Wan puts it, half a ship into the atmosphere and land it.  We have seen Anakin pilot ships in the previous films, but this sequence shows that George Lucas being off his rocker is not necessarily a bad thing.  I remember being in complete awe of this sequence when I saw this movie in the theater.  Also, and maybe this is just me, I find the scenes between Anakin Skywalker and Padme Amidala (Natalie Portman) to be quite good.  Anakin is still hesitant about expressing his feelings, but Padme is always there to comfort and reassure him.   Padme also sports a hairdo towards the beginning of the film that will make fans of the original trilogy smile.  Speaking of Padme, this is where I would like to start talking about the "how and why" of Star Wars.  We all know from the original trilogy that Anakin Skywalker turned to the dark side and became Darth Vader, and we also know that Luke and Leias' mother is not in these films. Revenge of the Sith explains all of this.  Anakin Skywalker begins to have visions of Padme dying in child birth, and turns to the dark side so that he can learn its power to save her.  This is an incredibly emotional hook that I find to be quite dark, and I particularly like it.  As far as Padmes' death is concerned, this is where you can start to psychologically analyze this movie.  At the climax of the film, Emperor Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) briefly touches the forehead of a mutilated Anakin Skywalker who is lying on the cliffs of Mustafar.  There is a theory among Star Wars fans that, because of how powerful the Emperor is, he drained Padmes' life-force from Anakin when he did this, and in so doing, the Emperor killed Padme.  I must admit that I cannot completely discount this theory.  There are several other theories including: Padme dying from Anakins' force-choke, Padme actually dying in child birth, and Padme dying from a broken heart which is the one I like best.  I do not find it completely implausible that, after learning that her one true love committed such horrible acts, Padme could not deal with it, and was so overcome with grief that she could not bear to live anymore.  Is it a little too science-fictiony for Star Wars?  Maybe.  However, one could argue that using mosquito blood to create dinosaurs was too science-fictiony for Jurassic Park but it works for that movie.  Also, during the lightsaber duel between Palpatine and Mace Windu, Palpatine just so happens to lose his lightsaber and supposedly give up the fight right when Anakin arrives.  Did Palpatine know that Anakin was going to show up to save him? Also, there is so much mystery as to how and why Palpatine ends up looking the way he does.  Did Mace Windu really do that to him, or was he using the Sith Mask technique to conceal his true features?  Perhaps more importantly, did he know that Anakin was going to get mutilated by Obi-Wan on Mustafar?  He always said that Anakin was going to be more powerful than him, so perhaps he sent him there on purpose so that Anakin would not overthrow him.  Moving on, I also love the fact that Anakin turns to the dark side while Obi-Wan is away on a mission.  I feel that it adds more emotional weight between the characters because Obi-Wan was not around to witness Anakins' acts because had he been there, he might have been able to help him.  This is the part of the blog where I address a major complaint about this movie among Star Wars fans.  There is a moment in the film where Yoda (Frank Oz) says, "Into hiding I must go.  Failed, I have", and to this day I hear people ask how and why he says this.  Let me explain:  During Yodas' duel with the Emperor, we quickly see a close-up on Yoda where his eyes narrow and he is visibly getting angry.  It is because of his anger that he is able to deflect the Dark Force Lightning back at the Emperor.  It is also because of his anger that Yoda realizes he can only defeat the Emperor if he turns to the dark side, which he refuses to do.  Yoda knows that if he turned evil, he would be even more powerful than the Emperor and the galaxy would be in even worse shape.  So, there.  Do with that explanation what you will.  Whew.  Okay, now I shall examine the negative aspects, and see if this movie really is the best of the prequels.

It always bugged me that we did not get to see the Clone Wars in Star Wars movie.  We saw the beginning of it in Attack of the Clones, and the end of it in Revenge of the Sith.  Now, was that made up for by the 2008 Clone Wars animated series?  Absolutely.  I just would have wanted to see more of the actual war on film.  One of the big problems I have with this film is the lack of time we see Darth Vader in his black suit.  The marketing campaign for the movie promised that we were going to see it, even going so far as to feature it prominently on the poster.  Then, it is only in the movie for five minutes!!!  What the damn hell?!?!?!  Now, towards the beginning of the film, Obi-Wan says, "Chancellor Palpatine, Sith Lords are our speciality."  Really?  Because I seem to remember you and Anakin got your butts whooped three years ago by Count Dooku.  Also, towards the beginning of the film, Chancellor Palpatine reminds Anakin of the time Anakin told him about what he did to the sandpeople after they killed Anakins' mother.  When did Anakin tell him this?  It was not during the last film, and it sure was not during the battle with Dooku.  In regards to the battle, why does General Grievous (Matthew Wood) not kill Anakin and Obi-Wan???  It seems to me that the situation would be more grave if they were killed, and Grievous escaped with the Chancellor.  Oh, right.  The Chancellor is really Sidious, and the battle is all one big test for Anakin to see if he is worthy of being Sidious' apprentice.  So, why was this not set up previously in the film?  It would have made the entire sequence less confusing.  Also, why is Obi-Wan nicknamed "The Negotiator"?  What events transpired for him to receive that title??  Moreover, why does Anakin not get a nickname??  What did he do wrong??  Also, what is the "business on Cato Neimoidia" that Obi-Wan refers to towards the beginning of the film after Anakin crash lands the ship??  When the hell did that "business" happen??  Later in the film, Obi-Wan tracks General Grievous to Utapau because the Jedi Council received a message that he was there.  The only thing is, before this scene happens, Yoda tells the Jedi Council, "Hiding in the Outer Rim, Grievous is".  How did Yoda know Grievous was there BEFORE they got the message???  Then, General Grievous sends the Separatists to Mustafar.  He says, "It is a volcanic planet.  You will be safe there."  How the blazes is a volcanic planet safe???  After that, Obi-Wan drops in on Grievous but does not kill him.  He instead gets surrounded by droids in the process.  It seems to me that Obi-Wan and Grievous get plenty of chances to kill each one another, and they do not follow through.  And how the hell is Grievous trained in the Jedi Arts???  He is a robot!!!  While Obi-Wan is on Utapau, Yoda goes to Kashyyyk.  Only, Yoda already has an escape pod hidden on the planet before he gets there!  How did it get there?  I am fairly certain Yoda did not arrive in it.  There is also a scene in the film where Obi-Wan says that Anakin has never let him down.  I mean, really??  Does he not remember three years ago when Anakin disobeyed him and left Naboo with Padme, thus getting the both of them captured???  Later, during the opera scene, Palpatine tells Anakin to remember his early lessons.  What lessons???  When did those happen??  Also, the scene where Anakin tells Mace Windu (Samuel L. Jackson) that Palpatine is a Sith Lord has several writing issues.  Anakin says, "I've just learned a terrible truth.  I think Chancellor Palpatine is a Sith Lord".  How can it be a truth if you only think it is??  Should you not know it??  Then, Mace Windu says, "We must move quickly if the Jedi Order is to survive".  Then they proceed to SLOWLY WALK down the hangar bay.  Why are they not running as fast as they can to the Chancellor's office to arrest him???  Speaking of which, why did they Jedi not investigate what was going on with the Senate, and arrest Palpatine sooner??  Why did Anakin have to spy on Palpatine?  Also, in the hangar bay scene, Mace Windu says, "If what you have told me is true, you will have gained my trust".  So, all that business three years ago about sending Anakin on his own mission and being confident with that decision was all a lie???  Next, in the duel between Palpatine and Mace Windu, Palpatine loses his lightsaber.  However, when he fights Yoda later he magically has it back?  How is this possible?  And when did he get it back.  Finally, during the lightsaber duel between Obi-Wan and Anakin at the climax of the film, Obi-Wan says, "It's over, Anakin.  I have the high ground."  What does that mean?  Has Anakin had bad luck going uphill before?  Also, I would liked to have seen some dialogue between Anakin and Padme where they discuss naming the babies instead of Padme just coming up with them on the spot.  And why does the fact that Padme is carrying twins such a mystery for a majority of the film?  There should have been a scene where Anakin and Padme find this out.

Well, there you have it.  In terms of the narrative and plot points, I personally think that Revenge of the Sith is the worst of the prequels.  It certainly feels more like Star Wars than the other two, but I just cannot get past the clunky dialogue and gaping plot holes.  I know that I have said in the past that I despise comparing sequels and prequels to one another, but if other Star Wars fans are doing it, so will I.

For me personally, the standout performance is Ian McDiarmid as Palpatine/Darth Sidious.  McDiarmid lets all the evil flow in this movie, and it is glorious to watch.  I love what he does in the opera scene when he is talking about Darth Plaeguis because you can tell that Sidious was Plaeguis' apprentice, even though he never actually says it, just by the way he delivers the dialogue.  Also, the scene where he gives Anakin his new title as Darth Vader is delightfully creepy.  If there is one good thing about this movie, it is McDiarmids' performance.

George Lucas returns to the directors' chair for Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith.  There are actually a number of things Lucas does well with this film.  I love that we see several tie-ins to the original trilogy, such as Obi-Wan saying, "So uncivilized" when he uses a blaster to kill General Grievous.  Next, the sequence where Anakin is at the Jedi Temple and Padme is at home, and they are both looking across Coruscant at one another is particularly moving.  You get the sense that even though Anakin does not want to do these evil things, he will because he wants to save his wife.  The sequence with The Great Jedi Purge is also emotional, although I would have preferred it look more practical and not so computer-generated.  I also enjoy the scene where Palpatine creates the Empire.  This scene shows how much influence he has over the Senate, and having him raise his hands in glory is so brilliant.  I have to say that what I love the most about this movie is that Lucas does not shy away from showing the consequences of Anakins' arrogance.  The scene where Anakin gets burned alive on the slopes of Mustafar is haunting to watch.  Every Star Wars fan wanted to know how Anakin got inside the black suit, and it was important to show those reasons on screen.  For the record, I would just like to say that I claimed that Anakin would be knighted Darth Vader before he got the suit BEFORE I saw the film.  I also love that the film is edited in a way that shows the birth of Vader, if you will, while Padme is dying at the same time.  The choice to cut back and forth between these events is extremely emotional, and gives off a different feeling than if they showed Padmes' death AFTER Vaders' birth.  Also, after Vader receives his armor, there is a scene where he shows his full fury with the Force on the medical bed and destroys everything.  This feels very much like an homage to Frankenstein, and Vader is the monster.  I love it.  Finally, at the end of the film, Yoda tells Obi-Wan that he will teach him how to commune with Qui-Gon Jinn, his old master.  It is reasonable to assume that communing with Qui-Gon is how Obi-Wan learns to become one with the Force, and speak to Luke in the original trilogy.  George Lucas puts forth his best effort in this film, and that is probably because this is the part of the story that he always wanted to tell.

Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith brings the original trilogy full circle, and blends the old with the new in a beautiful way.  Unfortunately, there are so many problems with the story line that you cannot help but roll your eyes at what George Lucas is thinking.  If you enjoy the original Star Wars trilogy, and want to see how Anakin turned to Vader and all that jazz, you will at least like this film.  If you hated the other two prequel movies, you will hate this one too.  That is all I have to say about this cinematic dungheep.



Thursday, January 26, 2017

Fathers and Sons: Part II

Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones is my least favorite film in the franchise.  I did not care for it fifteen years ago when I saw it in theaters four times, and I do not care for it today.  I can only describe how I feel about this movie by saying that it is only slightly better than The Phantom Menace.

Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones is the second chapter in the Star Wars saga, and tells the story of Obi-Wan Kenobis' investigation into an assassination attempt on Senator Amidala.  During this time, Anakin Skywalker and Padme pursue a forbidden love.  I have conflicting feelings about this film.  I have never been one of these film fans that compares a sequel to its predecessor.  I think that is unfair because I think every movie in an ongoing franchise should be judged on its own merits, and not on whether or not it is better than the film that came before it.  That being said, The Phantom Menace is so unspeakably awful that you cannot help but hope and think to yourself, "I hope this is better than the last one".  Even though I have never enjoyed Attack of the Clones, I do feel that there are more enjoyable ELEMENTS to this film than The Phantom Menace, and this makes the film marginally more watchable.  So let us begin with the enjoyable elements first.

I absolutely love the planet and creature design in the film.  From Geonosis to Kamino, the worlds and the creatures that inhabit them are quite interesting and visually spectacular.  World building has always been one of George Lucas' strengths. Also, as before, the sound design is top-notch.  Every machine, gadget, and creature has its own unique sound that brings the Star Wars universe to life.  The action sequences, what action there is, are also quite well done.  The last forty minutes of the movie has some of the best action in any of the Star Wars movies.  What makes these sequences so unique is the way the camera is used.  The way the camera quickly zooms in on the clone troopers, the tracking shots that follow the missiles, all of it is spectacular to witness.  For me personally, I also find Boba Fetts' (Daniel Logan) origin quite interesting.  Everyone just assumed that because of the armor he wears in the original trilogy that he was a Mandalorian, but in fact he is an unaltered clone of Jango Fett (Temuera Morrison) who is an established bounty hunter, and not Mandalorian either (he stole the Mandalorian armor on a previous mission that is not in the films).  Seeing a young Boba Fett co-pilot the Slave I is a wonderful tie-in to the original trilogy.  I also like that we see Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) fight Jango Fett without the use of his lightsaber.  Up until this film, Jedi have always used their lightsabers in combat, but this film shows that the Jedi can actually put up a fight in hand-to-hand combat as well.  Later in the film, we see the classic Lars homestead from A New Hope.  I love this sequence because see things that make us nostalgic, like the blue milk and the workspace where Luke Skywalker first saw Princess Leias' hologram message, but we also see some connections to the Skywalker family as well.  We learn that Owen Lars (Joel Edgerton) is Anakin Skywalkers' (Hayden Christensen) stepbrother, and that Owen Lars actually owned C-3PO (Anthony Daniels) for the first time when he was a young man.  I also enjoy the fact that we learn a bit about Count Dookus' (Christopher Lee) history.  We learn that he was once Yodas' (Frank Oz) apprentice, that he was Qui-Gon Jinns' master, and that he and the Geonosians actually collaborated on the design of the Death Star.  I am also a defender of Yoda using a lightsaber in combat.  I have constantly heard from other Star Wars fans that Yoda should not have a lightsaber.  My question is why not??  He is a Jedi Master!!!  Of course he would have a lightsaber, and the battle he has with Count Dooku is most impressive.  Unfortunately, this is where the list of positive things ends for this movie.  Now let us move on to the negative aspects...

The problems with Attack of the Clones start with the fact that the movie picks up ten years after The Phantom Menace, and a different actor plays Anakin Skywalker but the same actress plays Padme Amidala (Natalie Portman).  That makes no sense.  Why does this movie take place ten years after The Phantom Menace?  An even bigger question would be why The Phantom Menace takes place so long before A New Hope?  I cannot wrap my head around this concept.  Also, the Jedi seemed to have given up on the Sith Lord they were looking for in The Phantom Menace.  That seemed to be a big deal for them, and I do not understand why this was not part of the film.  Also, why does Jango Fett hire Zam Wesell (Leeanna Walsman) to kill Padme?  Why does he not do it himself??  Also, when Obi-Wan Kenobi is flying through the air on the assassin droid, why does Zam Wesell shoot the droid instead of shooting Kenobi???  During that chase scene, Obi-Wan says, "I hate it when he does that", referring to Anakin jumping out of the speeder to catch Wesell.  I thought that Jedi did not feel hate??  Another thing that gets under my skin about this movie is that the Republic starts making the Clone Army BEFORE the Separatists start building their droid army!!  This completely negates Yodas' feelings when he says, "Begun the Clone War has" because the Republic started the whole bloody thing!!!  Speaking of Yoda, how does he not know about the planet Kamino but some random buddy of Obi-Wan Kenobi named Dexter Jettster (Ronald Falk) knows all about it????  And who the blazes is Sifo Diyas???  I feel like that character was meant to be some sort of pivotal plot point, and it just failed miserably.  Also, for the love of Odin, Padme needs to stop calling Anakin "Ani".  I let that pass when he was 9 years old, but he is 19 now.  Stop it.  Also, why does Anakin Skywalker take Padme Amidala home to Naboo to hide from the people that are attempting to kill her??  Would it not make more sense to just keep going about your everyday life as if nothing is happening??  From the assassins' point of view, taking her home would create an opportunity for her to be exposed.  Another thing that bothers me, and it pains to talk about this, are the visual effects.  Some of the visual effects, particularly in the arena fight, are horrendous.  I would love to know who let this movie get past Editorial because it is quite clear that the actors are acting against a green screen background.  Later, in the scene where Anakin tells Padme what he did to the Tusken Raiders, Anakin yells, "He's holding me back!" and then proceeds to throw something small across the room.  This is just laughable.  If I was as aggravated as Anakin was, I would have turned that place upside-down with fury.  Also, there is a scene in the film where Yoda is instructing a class of younglings on how to use their lightsabers.  Why are these children standing so close together wielding these weapons???  It is a miracle that nobody had a limb severed.  Towards the climax of the film, Anakin and Padme stumble into a droid factory for what serves as an absolutely unnecessary action sequence.  And why is C-3PO there???  Why did he leave Tatooine??  Oh, right.  Because Owen Lars needs to not recognize him twenty-three years later when he buys him from the Jawas.  However, do you want to know what particularly grinds my gears???  The fact that Mace Windu (Samuel L. Jackson) says, "We're keepers of the peace.  Not soldiers." and then willingly leads an army of clone troopers into battle against the droid army of the Separatists!!!  Also, in the battle in the asteroid field between Jango Fett and Obi-Wan, Jango Fett literally hits every single thing around Obi-Wan except Obi-Wan himself!!!  How in the name of the Republic is this possible?!?!?!  Also, at the end of the movie when Obi-Wan and Anakin attempt to capture Count Dooku and bring him in for questioning, Obi-Wan and Anakin leave the arena to go into battle, but Count Dooku is still right there in the underground section of the arena!!!  They want to bring him in, and yet they just left the location where he is staying!!!!  The climactic lightsaber duel between Anakin and Count Dooku is filmed atrociously.  This is a sword fight.  I do not want to see close-ups of the actors' faces the entire time!!!!  Also,  in the scene where Yoda is mourning the beginning of the Clone Wars, all the chairs in the Jedi Council Chambers are mysteriously missing.  Did Yoda just use the Force to remove them???  What happened?!?!?!?  And why are C-3P0 and R2-D2 (Kenny Baker) at Anakin and Padmes' wedding?? I guess it makes sense for R2D2 to be there, but C3PO would blab his head off about their wedding which is supposed to be a secret.

Whew.  Okay, I was wrong.  There are even less enjoyable things about this film than in The Phantom Menace.  Seriously, where was the Script Supervisor this whole time???  I understand that George Lucas wanted to make these movies his way, but someone should have the power to say, "No, George.  That's stupid."  Now, let me talk about a couple of casting decisions that I actually support.

I actually like the way Hayden Christensen portrays Anakin Skywalker.  He plays Anakin as someone who always has an undercurrent of darkness that cannot wait to be released.  I personally enjoy this aspect of Christensens' craft because we realize that Anakin was truly destined to become Darth Vader.  The scene where he tells Padme about murdering the Tusken Raiders is particularly haunting.   If it were not for the creepy way he occasionally looks at Padme, I would have loved his performance.  Christensens' scenes with Ewan McGregor, Ian McDiarmid (Chancellor Palpatine) and Natalie Portman are also well done, and provide good foresight into the future of all of these characters.  I personally feel that this is an underappreciated performance by Christensen.

Samuel L. Jackson plays Mace Windu.  Windu is a man who is calm and able to control his emotions, but when the action starts he is one of the best Jedi Knights in the Order.  This is a well-rounded performance by Jackson because he plays Windu as someone who sets an example for the rest of the Order.  Windu uses the Force for knowledge, not to attack.  Of course, Jacksons' action sequences are the best part because we get to see him do what he does best.  I remember hearing cheers of applause in the theater when Windu decapitates Jango Fett.  I personally think this is an excellent performance by Jackson.

George Lucas is the director of Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones.  As I mentioned before, the action sequences are incredibly well shot.  The problem is that there is not enough of it.  I think this film falters from focusing on the love story too much, and also the fact that there is no substance behind the droid factory sequence.  If these problems had been fixed, this would have been a better movie.  I also enjoy the romantic scenes between Anakin and Padme.  The dialogue is over-dramatic, yes, but that is because Anakin is struggling to deal with his feelings.  The problems with this film are with the script, not the direction.  In my opinion, Lucas does a fine job with this film.

Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones is the worst film in the saga.  It has enjoyable elements, but overall it is a bland film that suffers from plot issues.  If you want to learn about Anakins' past as Obi-Wans' apprentice, then you will like the film for that aspect.  Otherwise, you are better off skipping it.






Tuesday, January 17, 2017

Fathers And Sons: Part I

For fifteen years, I defended Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace as a cinematic masterpiece.  Then, a little over a year ago, my friend Joshua Thomas and I decided to debate the film on camera so that everyone could see it.  It was then that I realized what a piece of cinematic dogshit this movie is.

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace is the story of two Jedi Knights who encounter a young Anakin Skywalker while the supposedly extinct Sith look to reclaim their glory.  Before I get started, I would like to make a case against Star Wars being deemed a "kids movie."  I would like to emphasize that this film is called Star WARS, which implies that there will be much violence throughout.  Also, if you care to look at the rating for these films, you will see that they are all rated either PG or PG-13 so it is probably a safe bet that no one under this particular age should be watching these films without parental supervision.  So here we go:  I am going to start with the good things about this film.  I personally think the action sequences are top-notch.  They are exciting to watch and, along with the lightsaber battles, they actually make the movie somewhat enjoyable.  Many people feel that the lightsaber duels feel too choreographed, but in my opinion they have passion behind them and feel energetic.  I also love the visual effects in the film, particularly in the podrace scene.  The computer generated characters look incredibly realistic, and all the set pieces and different planets are designed in exquisite detail.  I have heard many fans complain about the lack of the "used future" concept that was introduced in Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope.  My argument against that is that this film takes place 30 years prior and the Empire has not taken control over the galaxy, and therefore everything is more glossy and pristine.  Also, there were several things that were introduced in the original trilogy that raised certain questions: 1)Why does Darth Vader refer to the Emperor as Master? 2) How did the Emperor rise to power? 3) Who was on the Jedi Council, and what was its purpose?  All of these questions are answered in this film: 1) We are introduced to the Sith and The Rule of Two. 2)  Senator Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid), who is really Darth Sidious and deceiving both sides, begins to manipulate his way to being elected Supreme Chancellor.  I also enjoy the political aspect of this film because Queen Amidala (Natalie Portman) has to deal with the Supreme Chancellor and the Senate making a decision on what to about the Naboo Crisis, and there is much conflict going on with this situation. 3)  We see what the Jedi Council looks like, the characters within it, and what kind of missions they go on.  I also absolutely love the sound design, and John Williams' musical score.  Every individual ship and mechanical device has its own unique sound, and every bit of music in the film tells its own unique story.  There has also been talk among fans about how the battle droids pose no legitimate threat.  However, I like to believe that Darth Sidious is using the Trade Federation for their machinery while he concocts a brilliant scheme towards the creation of a clone trooper army.  After all, Sidious is a puppet master who pulls all the strings.  Therefore, he sees the battle droids as expendable.  As far as the good things about this movie go, that is about it.  Now on to the bad things:

In the opening crawl, it says that two Jedi Knights are dispatched to resolve the situation, but then we learn that Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) is not a Jedi Knight yet.  Was George Lucas getting ahead of himself on this?  Also, why do the Jedi Knights drink tea that was given to them by the people that are trying to kill them?  In what twisted universe does that make any sense at all?  Then we see Qui-Gon (Liam Neeson) cut through a blast door with his lightsaber, but yet he did not do that when they had to escape from the previous room that was filling with toxic gas?!?!  Also, why does the queen take so much time to commend R2D2 for getting them through the blockade??  George Lucas should have skipped this part, and moved on to what the Jedi Knights have to say.  Furthermore, R2D2 and Jar Jar Binks (Ahmed Best) serve no purpose going with Qui-Gon Jinn and the others to Mos Espa.  Jar Jar even says, "This sun doing murder to mesa skin."  They do absolutely nothing!!!  Speaking of Tatooine, a good forty minutes of the film is spent on that blasted planet.  You would think that because of how urgent of a matter it is for them to get to Coruscant they would find a faster way to leave Tatooine.  On a related note, after Anakin (Jake Lloyd) saves Jar Jar from Sebulba, Qui-Gon thanks him and walks away while Anakin aimlessly follows him.  There is nothing to indicate why Anakin would follow them, and yet he does so anyway.  Later in the film, we see Governor Sio Bibble (Oliver Ford Davies) say things like, "The death toll is catastrophic" and "A communications disruption can mean only one thing: invasion." Should he not say, "The death toll is non-existent" because not one of the Naboo prisoners gets killed?!?!  In fact, they are not even prisoners because nobody gets locked up!!!  They just get escorted around the city of Theed by battle droids while the Neimoidians attempt to force Queen Amidala to sign the treaty.  Also, is he absolutely sure that a communications disruption means only one thing??  Is he some kind of communications expert? Moving on to the treaty that the Queen has to sign, should the Neimoidians just forge the Queens' signature so they can proceed with making their invasion legal???  The only problem is, if the invasion is legal then there is no conflict in the story at all!!!  Speaking of the conflict, why does the droid army land on the opposite side of the planet where the Queens' palace is located?!?!  Why not just land near, or in, the city?!?!  Later, when the characters leave Naboo and escape the blockade, R2D2 magically repairs the shield generator.  My question is: is the shield generator not protected by the shields???? Why do the droid control ships immediately stop firing at them after R2D2 repairs the shields???  None of this makes sense at all!!!!  Also, was it not the Supreme Chancellor who dispatched the Jedi Knights to Naboo in the first place?  Yet, when they get to Coruscant, they do not even inform him of what happened.  They just shrug him off, and go speak to the Jedi Council.  Also, why exactly are the Jedi Knights incapable of warning the Naboo people about the droid army invasion BEFORE it actually starts?!  There is a sequence later in the film where Qui-Gon, Obi-Wan and everyone else return to Naboo, and the entire Trade Federation blockade is gone.  Where did they all go?!?!?!   The climactic battle on Naboo at the climax is where things really begin to go wonky.  Qui-Gon tells Anakin to find cover.  Anakin obeys by CLIMBING INTO A SHIP?!?!  Why????  He has more chance of being killed that way!!!  This moment launches a series of events that I refer to as "accidental heroics".  Anakin Skywalker is supposed to be incredibly strong with the Force, and yet everything he does while in the Naboo Starfighter is a result of sheer dumb luck.  His piloting skills are purely accidental.  Also, if Darth Sidious ordrered the Neimoidians to wipe out the Gungans, why do the battle droids take prisoners????

All of this negativity adds up to one of the biggest disappointments in cinematic history.  Did George Lucas have an ego problem, and let his success go to his head?  What happened to the genius that created the original trilogy?  The world may never know.  Anyway, moving on:

Liam Neeson plays Qui-Gon Jinn.  Qui-Gon is a rebellious Jedi who does not follow the Jedi Code, and does not even bow when in the presence of the Jedi Council.  Some would see this as disrespectful, but Neeson plays the character in such a way that makes Qui-Gon confident, and a tad arrogant, about why he is a Jedi Master. While Qui-Gon takes risks, he never does anything rash enough to get himself expelled from the Jedi Order. At the same time, he is calm and collected about every situation. This is a minimalist performance at its finest by Neeson.

Ewan McGregor, in the role that made him a star, plays Obi-Wan Kenobi.  This younger version of Kenobi is headstrong, makes bad jokes, and even gets a little irritated at times.  However, what McGregor does brilliantly is give subtle hints that he will eventually become the Alec Guinness version of the character.  McGregor is fantastic in the role not just because of the fight sequences he is in, but also because he adds more dimensions to the character, as he does in Qui-Gons' death scene.  This scene is emotional because of how well McGregor and Neeson delivered their dialogue.  McGregors' performance as Obi-Wan Kenobi deserves all the praise it has ever received.

Ahmed Best plays Jar Jar Binks.  I know that I am going to get so much hate for saying this, but I actually like this character for a couple of reasons: 1) Much like C-3PO and R2D2 in Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope, Jar Jar Binks is a funny character right down to his physical movements, and he is also extremely crucial to the story because 2) Without Jar Jar Binks, STAR WARS DOES NOT HAPPEN!!!!  Without Jar Jar, Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan would have never made it to Theed to rescue Queen Amidala so that she could plead her case to the Senate and meet her future husband along the way!!!  Never before has such a hated character been so important to the story.  Congratulations, George Lucas!!!  You have done it!!!!

Ray Park plays Darth Maul.  What is ironic about Darth Maul is that he is probably the coolest character in all of Star Wars, and yet he dies ( not really, watch The Clone Wars) at the end of the movie.  Park took a character that says 31 words in the entire film, and turned him into a menacing Sith apprentice.  The fact that Park is a martial artist himself adds so much credibility to his physical performance as Darth Maul.  If Darth Maul ends up being the role that Ray Park is best known for, that will not be so bad.

Jake Lloyd plays Anakin Skywalker.  I personally love Lloyds' performance because it feels genuine, and not rehearsed in any way.  His scenes with Natalie Portman and Liam Neeson are quite good, and his character he even displays bits of anger and impatience which we all know will come into play later in his life.  This is a heartfelt performance by Lloyd.

George Lucas is the director of Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace.  Firstly, I have to say that the last forty minutes of the film is edited perfectly.  All the characters get an equal amount of screen time that finally culminates in its epic finale.  Also, Lucas a filmmaker always get at least serviceable performances out of his actors, and this film is no different.  The problems are with the script, and story points.  Could Lucas have used less bluescreen and filmed more footage on actual locations and sets?  Probably.  Is Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace a poorly directed film?  I can only answer that by saying that I have seen worse.  Is this film as good as Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope?  Absolutely not.

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace has many good elements, but because of the plot holes and illogical narrative the film falls short of being great .  If this was the first Star Wars movie you ever saw, you might enjoy watching it for the nostalgia factor, but that is about it.  If you are a Star Wars fan you will HATE this movie, so do not waste your time.